Most people are aware of the risk of lenders coming after them for a deficiency judgment after a foreclosure and they know how this may be avoided.  But few people understand or appreciate the tax liability that also can occur with any unpaid loan. But there also are times that this is avoidable.

Under our Federal Tax Law, anytime you owe money to someone else and then don’t have to pay it, “debt forgiveness” occurs (unless the lender gifts the debt to you which is not likely). The IRS says if you owed it, you must have had the money to pay it. So, if you got to keep that money, it must be income that they can tax you on.  That’s right, even if you never had this “phantom income”, it is taxable if the lender doesn’t get paid in full whether due to foreclosure, deed in lieu, or even a short-sale.  Although generally the foregiveness is shown by the lender giving you a 1099 tax form, the tax code doesn’t require this.  So, if your home short-sells for $100,000 less than you owed, you now have $100,000 of taxable income….maybe.

In December, 2007, the Federal Government passed The Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 which generally excludes debt forgiveness from taxation if  it occurs on your principal residence from 2007 through 2013 (there are some restrictions).   Many states have adopted similar laws providing the same relief for state taxes. However, California’s similar law ended 12/31/08. We’re awaiting a bill to extend it but with CA’s budget mess, this may not happen soon if at all.

So, they key point is that the Relief only applies on the home you actually live-in. If you rent out your home or leave it vacant and go live somewhere else. Your debt forgiveness relief may be lost and you may be looking at a high income tax bill from the IRS and your state.

If you need further assistance or have legal or real estate questions, feel free to e-mail me at sjbeede@bpelaw.com